This Under-the-Radar Caribbean Island Has Reef Sharks, Beach Bungalows, and a Different Kind of Dive Resort

You spend the day diving bottomless blue holes. Discovering thick finger coral and hobnobbing with reef sharks, eagle rays and regal seahorses. Then you get out of the water and find the perfect sunset on a totally uncrowded white-sand beach.  I remember the first time I visited Cape Eleuthera, way down at the southeastern corner of the long, thin island of Eleuthera in The Bahamas. I felt it. I absorbed it. The property was like its own distinct corner of the earth, pristine, quiet. With a few well-placed Christmas lights, I’d have surely found myself inside the old Corona commercial.