3 Netflix Movies With Bad Rotten Tomatoes Scores That Are Good (October 2025)

Many movie fans — including the Watch With Us team — often reference Rotten Tomatoes scores as indicators of a movie’s quality. And yes, a high percentage of positive reviews usually means a film is worth the hype. But all art is subjective, and sometimes critics just don’t see things the same way audiences do. So this month, when you’re browsing Netflix, don’t skip past a film just because of its low score. We’ve rounded up three movies that critics panned but we genuinely love — and we think you might too. ‘Wet Hot American Summer’ (2001) Rotten Tomatoes score — 39 percent The Watch With Us